AI-Powered Creativity: The Future of Advertising or Just a Gimmick?

Let’s be real—if you work in advertising, you’ve either played with AI tools or panicked about them taking your job (or both, in the same afternoon). One minute, you’re marveling at how ChatGPT can punch out a halfway decent headline; the next, you’re rolling your eyes at yet another AI-generated nightmare ad with six-fingered models and gibberish text. So… is AI the creative revolution we’ve been waiting for, or just the latest overhyped gimmick?

AI as the New Intern (That Never Sleeps)

AI is great at cranking out first drafts—headlines, captions, script outlines. Need 20 variations of a tagline in 10 seconds? Done. But let’s be honest, AI is like that eager intern who almost gets it but still needs a human to step in and make it work. It generates words, not ideas. And while it might suggest “Experience the Future of Flavor” for your client’s new energy drink, it’s still the creative team that has to find the magic.

The Good: AI as a Creative Wingman

For agencies that move at the speed of the internet (aka all of them), AI is already proving to be a solid co-pilot. Moodboards, rough video cuts, instant transcriptions, quick design tweaks—AI streamlines the grunt work so creatives can focus on actual creativity. Think of it like an espresso shot for your workflow.

The Bad: When AI Gets It… Wrong.

But AI still fumbles. Hard. We’ve seen brands drop AI-generated campaigns only to get roasted online for their uncanny-valley weirdness. (Shoutout to the beer brand that released an AI ad where partygoers had melting faces—very on-brand for a dystopian sci-fi thriller, not so much for a backyard BBQ vibe.)

In November 2024, Coca-Cola released a 15-second AI-generated Christmas commercial intended to echo their nostalgic 1995 “Holidays Are Coming” campaign. Instead, the ad was met with criticism, with viewers describing it as a “creepy dystopian nightmare.” Technical flaws and the absence of traditional elements, like Santa Claus, led to negative reception. Despite the backlash, Coca-Cola defended their approach, emphasizing the collaboration between humans and AI in creating the commercial.

AI isn’t here to replace creatives—it’s here to force us to level up. The agencies that will thrive aren’t the ones trying to replace human originality with machine efficiency. They’re the ones combining the two—using AI to amplify ideas, not generate them from scratch. The real winners? The creatives who know how to use AI without letting AI use them.

So yeah—AI in advertising? Not a gimmick, but also not the genius overlord some fear (or hope) it will be. Just another tool in the arsenal. The future belongs to the ones who know how to wield it.

AI Won’t Replace Creatives—But Creatives Who Use AI Will Win

Let’s be honest: the best advertising has always been about human insight, emotion, and storytelling. AI might help streamline the process, but it can’t replace the cultural instincts that make an idea hit. The agencies and brands winning right now aren’t just blindly handing over their creative strategy to algorithms—they’re using AI to work smarter, not lazier. From personalized ad targeting to dynamic content creation, AI is a tool, not a takeover. And the creatives who master it? They’ll be the ones leading the charge.

So, Are We the Machines Now?

At the end of the day, AI isn’t some creative messiah, nor is it the villain sneaking in to steal our jobs. It’s just another tool—one that’s only as good as the humans using it. The best ideas? They still come from late-night brainstorms, shower thoughts, and those weird moments when something just clicks. AI might help us get there faster, but it won’t do the work for us.

So, no, I’m not worried about being replaced by a chatbot anytime soon. But I am keeping one on standby to handle the boring stuff while I focus on the fun part—being creative, pushing boundaries, and making things that actually resonate. Because if AI is coming for anything, it’s busywork. And honestly? It can have it.

Thank you for spending time at the Trend Desk